So, for the August 2018 #TheMerryWriter challenge started by Ari Meghlen and Rachel Poli, the second day’s question was “Is there a genre you would never write?”
It was a tough question to answer. My tastes are incredibly varied already and can change a lot. A desire to move away from fire-eating hyperbole on my part made it even harder. Finally, the vague nature of what constitutes certain “genres” at all makes it tougher.
I don’t want to say I’d never write a certain genre, but certain ones are lower on my priority list. The one I tweeted was “classic Westerns”. I’ve never been terribly interested in them past watching The Magnificent Seven as a child, and if I’m not into reading them, then writing them, well, yeah.
However, a lot of genres I would gladly write-the adventure genre, part of the “cheap thriller” genre I love, has been clearly inspired by classic Westerns. So genres are not easy to separate.
Other genres low on my list:
- Outright horror, especially cosmic horror. Not really for me, but I can see the appeal.
- Contemporary romance. For the most part I’m not in the demographic, so that’s pretty self-explanatory.
- Mysteries. Argh. The problem is a spectacular true crime book by The Wire creator David Simon called Homicide: A Year On The Killing Streets. With that being as piercing as it is, traditional mysteries look especially formulaic and unrealistic. That being said, I do like the concept more.
- Zombies. At least shambler zombies. Too often they become a “theme park apocalypse”.
- Urban Fantasy. Fantasy overall is fairly low, but urban fantasy is even lower. I like it in theory, it’s just too often I see it falling. It might just be me seeing poor examples, but I think a lot of the time it tries to have its cake (modern relatable characters and the fantastic!) and eat it too (too neatly segmenting off the societies), and that annoys me.
- Legal thrillers. I’m not a lawyer, self-explanatory.
This is of course my personal taste and I have nothing against the genres or anyone who likes them. And my opinion could very well change again.
Great list! This was a tough question because you never know how your tastes may change down the road but there are quite a few I barely read so I wouldn’t write. I’ve tried fantasy before, but not urban fantasy. Everything else I agree with it. Except for the mysteries. That’s the genre I main in. 😛
LikeLike